I woke up yesterday rather energised after reading Leslie Hazeltonâs blog post (www.accidentaltheologist.com) on Islamophobia and Anti-Semitism. Itâs something I totally agree with her with. I was so impressed by her blogpost that Iâve decided to comment on it as well.
Itâs true that it wasnât until I came to the UK when I encountered antisemitism. Before, it was always textbook stuff you read about. However, perhaps with war on Gaza, then the floatilla and more Israel-Palestine issue, the level of antisemitism has definitely risen. Of course, the other side is also true, with 9/11, July 7th, uprising in the Middle East, Islamophobia â as much as I hate that word â has also risen. Itâs one thing if you know a Jew or a Muslim and you say, oh, itâs ok, heâs a moderate Jew/Muslim, heâs a nice guy â but yet have entrenched views about âthe Jewsâ or âthe Muslimsâ. Too often a time I came across a Muslim telling me, âthose Jews blah blah blah blah blahâ and perhaps because Iâve studied the religion so in depth during my A-Levels that I get a great sense of repulsion upon hearing it. I am quite vocal about my distaste towards antisemetic comments, and most Muslims who have seen that side of find me extremely strange. Perhaps I am. I am not Jewish, and I hate with utter rage what they are doing to the Palestinians, but I will voice for them (your so call moderate Jews) if necessary. Then they will say, âOh, I donât hate Jews, I just hate the Zionists.â (Because in the Quran there are a lot of reference to Jews, and how they are also Godâs people but has issues with them because of their inability to accept Jesus and Muhammed as prophets.) To me, someone who lives in diaspora for 7 years now, I understand the desire for a homeland. Call them Zionists, Israelis whatever you want, they do deserve a homeland. However, I know how sensitive the issue of Jerusalem is and I shall not go into the debate here. Either way, what Leslie Hazleton said on her blogpost, I 100% agree with. Perhaps the whole Peter King incident is playing out in America right now, (which I have to say, I am very impressed with the turnout against this âbigotâ), everyone is suddenly talking about Islamophobia and whether the mosques in America are run by moderate Muslim populations or those with extremists view.
Letâs explore this Peter King issue a little bit further for the fun of it. To understand this issue, you must understand the Muslim demographics of America. For those of us living across the Atlantic, it is a very different story. Most Muslims living in Britain are those who newly immigrated here from the subcontinent, or those of second generation â and in all honesty, a lot of the 3rd and 4th generations have move on from Islam. In America though, youâve got a very different story. In America, most Muslims are well educated and from a well-to-do family. They usually live in affluent part of town, and they fully embrace the American culture. I would imagine if you asked them where they came from, they will tell you they are American. Perhaps itâs the whole patriotism instilled in Americans from young â but they are part of the American life. Therefore, when someone like Peter King comes out to talk about those extremists living in the Muslim communities, suddenly a large population who in a way is âemancipatedâ and âintegratedâ into the American society suddenly got cherry-picked to be called a âterroristâ. To me, it resonates with what I read about Nazi Germany when the Jews were the scapegoat of the society.
I guess to a lot of people, religious people, whether they be Muslims, Christians, Jews, Buddhists, Hindus etc, are someone who are incompatible with modern society (c.f. the Hasidic Jews and the reform Jews). In a way, itâs the result of the slow secularisation of humanity â yes, that is the term I shall use. Ever since Nietzche declared God is dead in Gay Science, no matter how radical it was at the time, slowly anchors into society. You see, this is why I want to do Philosophy: ideologies affect people trough generations. Yet, people are seldom aware of the level of brainwashing going around. Leslie Hazelton mentioned the protocols of the elders of Zion, the Russian spy document, which I am sure Iâve mentioned before on my blog as well, is a great example of such floating ideology â which to my surprise (and dismay) the Muslim brotherhood in Egypt is passing out. The problem with ideologies are, once it becomes popularised, it becomes a âpseudo-truthâ. I use the word pseudo because I think itâs only true to the beholder of the truth. I guess people can say the same for everything else that people believe. However, I do believe there is an ultimate truth which is shielded from the facade of our world â a reality beyond the understanding of human intellect and logic.
What I really wanted to say is that our mentality does not transcend history. I wasnât sure who I was listening to â must be Sheikh Hamza Yusuf, my favourite Islamic scholar who teaches in Stanford and UC Berkeley â who said that his philosophy teacher was someone who had such entrenched view; It was impossible for someone to challenge his core principles because he thought so deeply about them. Yet, if we look at anyone in our society, we get so easily influenced by people around us, by a news article we read or by a magazine we follow that our views waffles â we donât think about these issues. I find it very difficult to debate with people on political issues which I canât verify with my own experience or some facts. I am quite a deep thinker. Itâs been a while since Iâve really engage myself in thought â meditate I suppose. I remember when I did A-levels Philosophy, my head would be in constant state of âexplosionâ â I guess itâs where they coined the phrase âmind-blowingâ because you really feel your mind blowing (up). I guess itâs time like that where you can truly connect with your soul and feel what is important to you.
I have quite deep entrenched views about a lot of things and Iâm not someone who can easily change. Perhaps anti-semitism is one thing I have really thought about for a long time even coming face to face to it, that when I encounter it, I tend to feel nausea hearing it. At least with Islamophobia I can say, hey, Iâm a Muslim who prays 5 times a day, I donât think any rational person would imagine me extreme (you know what I mean
) by any measure. Then again, most of my non-Muslim friends would point to those âterroristsâ and say, they are not true Muslims.
Iâve been to so many places in the world, most people Iâve come across asks about Islam out of respect and curiosity instead of hostility. I do believe there is a general goodness in society, and I wish I could, inshaâallah, understand more of the ârealityâ which is so often clouded by our everyday lives.
I just did a search online and found this I would like to share: